I tried this myself and based in on shelf price and I did NOT get the catalina. This is what I purchased.
2 Scope Mouth Wash ($4.29) $3.79 each
1 Pantene Shampoo ($3.49) $2.99
3 Crest Toothpaste ($2.49) $1.99 each
2 Cover Girl Brow Pencil ($2.99) $0.99 each
Total shelf price: $25.52
Total Sale price: $18.52
Total after coupons: $7.02
So, I thought that it was only working on sale price. But, reader Megh did a deal on shelf price and the $10 catalina printed (shown below) so I’m not sure what the deal is. But, I would recommend just basing it on the sale price as there are still good deals even at the sale price.
Here are the items in the deal:
Proctor & Gamble: Buy $25 Get $10 Catalina
Here are some Deal Ideas:
If you have any great deal you have come up with let us know and I’ll add them to the post.