Pathmark: Cheap GM Cereal and Possbile Free Milk

Reader Jen let me know that she purchased 4 Fiber One Cereals at Pathmark and received a catalina for a Free milk.  Now I know that they free milk is going on at A&P but it was not listed in the Pathmark circular. And at A&P it’s a Free milk catalina wyb 3 boxes of General Mills cereals.   So here are some deals you can try:

Buy 3 Fiber One Honey Clusters or Raisin Bran ($1.79 each) $5.37
use $0.75/1 from the 4/18 SmartSource insert
or use $0.50/1 from the 5/9 SmartSource insert
Pay: as low as $0.87
Get a Catalina for a free milk

Buy 3 Cheerios $(1.79 each) $5.37
use $0.55/1 Cheerios Printable
or use $0.55/1 Cheerios Printable
Pay: $2.07
Get a Catalina for a free milk

Let us know if this worked for you!

The links in the post above may be affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.
  • Christine

    I bought 4 Cheerio’s at Pathmark and got a 3.75 catalina OYNO. I purchased the on sale Cheerios.

    Just an fyi. No other info was on the Cat as to why I receieved it.


  • Jen from Philly

    I bought 4 Fiber One w/ Raisins and got the cat! be careful when picking out the fiber one’s because the shredded wheat and original are not included. I’ve never gotten a milk cat before, any idea if it will give overage if the milk is less then $3.75?

  • Rei

    Has anyone gotten the CAT coupon for just buying 3? I wonder if we can mix & match?!