A&P and Superfresh Match Ups 2/18 – 2/24

Here are some highlights at A&P and Superfresh this week.  The match ups are actually done off of the A&P circular for North Jersey but most sale items are the same for Superfresh.  However, just be sure to check your circular to check your own prices.  Coupons are shown doubled up to $.99.

How to Create Your Custom Shopping List:
  • Click on the box next to the item you would like to buy at the store
  • The item will be placed in your shopping list.
  • The list will appear from the right bottom of this site
  • Once you are done, click print.
  • Note that if you leave this post, you will lose your list.

Click the link below to see the entire A&P/Superfresh Match Ups for this week and to create your own shopping list.

If you are reading this in a reader or email, you will need to click onto the site be able to print your list.


Most Catalinas are based on the shelf price of the item when calculating the price. Please be sure to check your shelf prices as they may vary from the ones listed here. The deals shown are only suggestions to get you started. These deals have not been confirmed so you may want to check back in the comments to see if anyone has been successful doing them.


NOTE: If your catalinas do not print, the best thing to do it to contact Catalina Marketing. Their info is: 1-888-826-8766 or via email ncsc@catalinamarketing.com.

The links in the post above may be affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.
  • Laurie

    hi cindy, what zip code are you using to find the Texas Toast coupon? thanks!

    • Cindy

      Oh shoot…I keep forgetting that coupon is gone. Sorry about that.

      • Melissa

        I can still see it on the Smartsource site, right on the first page, under 07039:

        Save 50¢ On Any One Flavor The Original Texas Toast™ Croutons In The Grocery Section

        I can’t figure out how to link it though.

  • Kym

    Went to my local Superfresh the other day and after I had done all my shopping was told by the cashier they no longer accept internet coupons. Any one else encounter this??

    • jeannine favretto

      Hi Kim,

      Just went to Superfresh today and used several internet coupons with no problem. The only time I have had an issue there is using an internet coupon that includes a free item, they will not accept those.

    • jessa

      just went to superfresh today, got my 6 duncan brownies for free, i use 6 internet coupons at self service check out.

  • anna

    What am i missing here?

    Duncan Hines Brownies $1- 50cents coupon=50cents.

    How are they free????????//

    • Cindy

      The coupons double taking off $1.00. That is how they are free

  • Carrie

    Just came back from A&P and bought 3 Blue Bunny ice creams and did not recieve a cat, I will be contacting them today, just wanted to give a heads up.

    • Cindy

      What was your shelf price on the Blue Bunny?

      • Carrie

        $5.59 shelf price. I went to customer service and they said it was on sale prices – I did try to explain to them that I have always recieved them on the shelf price and they said ‘it’s never on the sale price’ so I stopped arguing and will just contact cat on tuesday.

        • Cindy

          Hmm odd. Yes, you always a lot more luck when contacting catalina marketing then trying to discuss it with customer service. Thanks for the heads up.

  • Heatherlyn

    Went to Superfresh today. They wouldn’t let me use all the $1 off BlueBunny today. I could only use one. Same thing with the Pennsylvania Noodles. They scanned all of my coupons like I was stealing. I will not be shopping there again.

  • Lisa

    When I began couponing almost two years ago I was treated the same way in A&P. I stood my ground and told them that’s what coupons are for and that I am not stealing or doing anything wrong. Since then they have never done that again and I just help my head high and kept shopping. I went home and ranted and raved to my husband that I wasn’t going to shop there anymore and that they treated me like a criminal. However, I kept shopping there and many of the emoployees have started couponing since they see how much I save!

    • Heatherlyn

      Thanks Lisa! I appreciate it. It was annoying. I will go back with their coupon policy in hand!

  • Jim

    Here is a good one:

    Purdue Oven Ready Chicken (6#) – $5.99 (with 40% off deal)
    Less: $2 Zaver
    Less: $2 printable

    6# roasting chicken (in the oven as we speak) for $1.99

    • Jim

      Just a follow-up – Chix was very easy and really good. Done in 1.5 hours. tender, fall off the bone good. Did not try the suggestion for gravy.

      You can do the deal at least twice. I went back into my Zavers account and was able to add another coupon again (and a diet dr pepper which is $1 off one 2 ltr and its good at pathmark (they are $1 each this week).

  • anna

    i can not find the 70cent coupon for Kellogs Cinnamon cereal. It seems to have been replaced with one of the other coupons

  • Sharon Sedita

    SuperFresh was a BUST today!!! Only taking 2 internet coupons PER transaction!!! Will be sending an email-CRAZY policy!!!

  • Shell

    If the blue bunny deal works, I just got an email from them today with a $2/1 coupon… so you can end up spending $3 for the ice cream and getting $3 back! And even if the catalina doesn’t print it’s a good deal.

  • there is a .50 printable for the texas toast croutons on the smart source coupon site. I just printed it. It will be free at A&P