Free I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter at A&P and Pathmark!

I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter Coupon

This morning I posted about the awesome Unilever Deals at A&P and Pathmark.  But, I forgot that there is a $1/1 I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter Coupon available to print.  And, since the coupons only allow for 2 “like” coupons per transaction, you can now score Free I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter.

Print: I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter Coupon (32115)

Here is the deal:


How to Change the Zip Code:

To change the zip code make sure you click the local tab, then type in the zip code and press enter, then click coupons again. If you don’t see the local tab then try another browser. It doesn’t always show up in Firefox. If you are still having trouble changing the zip, try using this link for

The links in the post above may be affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.
  • Nancy


    This deal is even better than you stated- Pay $4.57, get back TWO $5 Catalinas, equals free plus a $$4.43 money maker!

    • Cindy

      Why 2 catalinas? I did the deal today and received 1.

    • Cindy

      Oh wait I see what you are saying. Yes, I did receive 2 but I used one to pay for the second transaction. The final result is what I had paid and what was left after the second transaction.

  • linda

    the icbinb is $1.99 in cherry hill

  • Jodi

    Question on Catalinas – A store has to opt in to a Catalina, right? The Catalinas aren’t done by the manufacturer? So my store won’t necessarily have a catalina that I see you post about, even if they run other catalinas sometimes?

    • Cindy

      Are you referring to an A&P or Pathmark store or some other store? This deal is running at A&P and Pathmark stores only this week.

  • Jaime

    At the Patterson NY store the ICBINB Light 2 pk (15 oz) is on unadvertised special for 1.99. I don’t know if the other ICBINB products are ringing up at this price. It is still qualifying for the Unilever deal on the $3.99 shelf price.